{
  "schema": 1,
  "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-07-14T15:17:52Z",
  "lane": "evidence_review",
  "decision": "G1_REJECT",
  "candidate": {
    "version": "v042",
    "source_sha256": "526470960faab8d6a3963b3574aac8d56941187d23807163827a0fa25fab83c5",
    "geometry_fingerprint": "e2a667508463de9c89207b48382684660bfe4552533c3f4b000e7667115007f7",
    "vertices": 49626,
    "faces": 49624,
    "topology_islands": 1,
    "boundary_edges": 0,
    "nonmanifold_edges": 0
  },
  "review_evidence": {
    "locked_view_contract": "CAMERA_MANIFEST_V2, fixed Hc 2.5, no subject auto-fit",
    "clay_contact_sha256": "4a7de9e4008540c50c38d9fca8aa20764c310491cd65eddb80b651d0f39a54ec",
    "wire_contact_sha256": "885e865cce85d69c90c51ecb8bb9f1fbac38cb1aa684545c075910b3bf853b14",
    "v041_comparison_clay_sha256": "fc88ea04d8d82a4d45775f7e6553d9666af1924e4ef744a43b38133cd2b512d2",
    "reference_use": "observed standing photographs controlled form judgment; generated turnaround was consulted only as labeled hidden-view inference",
    "generated_turnaround_sha256": "9a640c76ec2d5036efd94d8f808141326868251ae6bc29262c2fc1b5e1b14676",
    "reviewers": [
      "primary Codex visual review",
      "independent adversarial Codex subagent review"
    ]
  },
  "genuine_improvements_over_v041": [
    "seventeen construction islands became one closed manifold review surface",
    "former part seams no longer block cross-surface sculpt strokes",
    "shoulder shelf, croup cutoff, and tail-root junction are slightly softer",
    "muzzle is marginally shorter and broader",
    "ground contacts, symmetry, and selected macro proportions survived the union"
  ],
  "ranked_failures": [
    {
      "rank": 1,
      "severity": "critical",
      "region": "head_and_neck",
      "finding": "The head remains a coat-inflated dome over a featureless pipe muzzle, with no readable stop, orbit, cheek, jaw, mouth corner, nose plane, or throat. The neck is a large tapered column and the ears are flat blades without credible roots or leather volume."
    },
    {
      "rank": 2,
      "severity": "critical",
      "region": "shoulder_chest_and_torso",
      "finding": "The body is still a rectangular tube with nearly uniform cross-section. It lacks a vertically oval ribcage, scapular plane, withers transition, caudally directed upper arm, pectoral mass, restrained abdominal tuck, and readable loin."
    },
    {
      "rank": 3,
      "severity": "critical",
      "region": "pelvis_haunch_and_hind_chain",
      "finding": "The hind chain remains mechanical and high-Z, without sufficient thigh, gluteal, or hamstring mass. The rear reads as a rounded vertical cap and the tail as a short bent extrusion."
    },
    {
      "rank": 4,
      "severity": "severe",
      "region": "limbs_and_paws",
      "finding": "Forelegs are smooth load-bearing posts, hind legs are thin rods, and paws are tiny flat pads without credible forward footprint or digit structure."
    },
    {
      "rank": 5,
      "severity": "severe",
      "region": "overall_read",
      "finding": "Mass distribution reads as a generic quadruped mannequin rather than the compact, deep-bodied Cockapoo seen in observed side and rear-quarter photographs."
    }
  ],
  "density_assessment": "The uniform voxel-remesh density produces clean shading and hides primitive intersections, but it does not create anatomical or deformation flow around the face, shoulder, hip, paws, or tail base. The silhouette remains essentially v041 with softened edges. This topology is disposable sculpt clay only.",
  "status_split": {
    "anatomy_g1": "REJECT",
    "likeness_g1b": "NOT_EVALUABLE",
    "production_topology": "BLOCKED",
    "rig": "BLOCKED",
    "groom": "BLOCKED",
    "animation": "BLOCKED",
    "final_render": "BLOCKED"
  },
  "next_bounded_strategy": [
    "Freeze v042 as technical evidence and duplicate it as a v043 sculpt experiment.",
    "Run one bounded manual primary-form session with large brushes and non-rendering skeletal landmarks; stop scripted mask and smoothing passes.",
    "Build ribcage, waist, pelvis, scapula and upper-arm, and thigh masses.",
    "Correct limb chains and paw footprints.",
    "Rebuild neck, skull, muzzle, jaw, ear roots, and basic facial planes.",
    "Render the same fixed profile, front, rear three-quarter, and top views after each region.",
    "If the session cannot remove the tube, pillar, and dome read simultaneously, discard this foundation and run a licensed anatomy-first canine-base bakeoff."
  ],
  "strongest_supportable_claim": "v042 proves a reproducible copy-only native union and continuity workflow plus guarded process capture. It does not establish acceptable canine anatomy or Cockapoo likeness.",
  "human_approval_required": true
}