{
  "schema": 1,
  "reviewed_at_utc": "2026-07-14T15:58:27Z",
  "lane": "evidence_review",
  "decision": "G1_REJECT",
  "strategy_decision": "TRIGGER_LICENSED_ANATOMY_FIRST_CANINE_BASE_BAKEOFF",
  "candidate": {
    "version": "v043",
    "source_sha256": "835688aa96ee8a742adf5f9b7c80ea9caf9e456a932f6582566fe2f48e5ddf9d",
    "geometry_fingerprint": "e56f3e9a5b033f3d8a777e236eea5633069bea44d0754bc10789d6625d1e3dea",
    "vertices": 49626,
    "faces": 49624,
    "topology_islands": 1,
    "boundary_edges": 0,
    "nonmanifold_edges": 0
  },
  "review_evidence": {
    "locked_view_contract": "CAMERA_MANIFEST_V2, fixed Hc 2.5, no subject auto-fit",
    "clay_contact_sha256": "e28e6423814cf3a93fee8be1884f20628bd891f126e105bf210385fc4e348112",
    "wire_contact_sha256": "9e4779c412ee36fefa111b51f81e887c25339bdc4f503800b6dd09adb9deff5c",
    "reference_use": "Observed standing photographs controlled form judgment; no generated view was treated as ground truth.",
    "reviewers": [
      "primary Codex visual review",
      "independent adversarial Codex subagent review"
    ]
  },
  "experiment_result": {
    "bounded_duration_seconds": 300.006667,
    "source_displacement_mean": 0.00118366,
    "source_displacement_p95": 0.00281484,
    "source_displacement_max": 0.11433135,
    "positive_x_vertices_moved_over_0_001": 2586,
    "negative_x_vertices_moved_over_0_001": 428,
    "mirror_error_mean_before": 0.00132,
    "mirror_error_mean_after": 0.00222,
    "mirror_error_max_before": 0.0154,
    "mirror_error_max_after": 0.0534,
    "conclusion": "The manual pass made small broad-volume changes but did not materially improve canine massing and introduced visible asymmetric dents and lumps."
  },
  "ranked_failures": [
    {
      "rank": 1,
      "severity": "critical",
      "region": "overall_construction",
      "finding": "The fixed views retain a rectangular tube torso, pillar forelegs, thin mechanical hind chain, dome-and-pipe head, column neck, blade ears, flat paws, and hooked tail extrusion."
    },
    {
      "rank": 2,
      "severity": "critical",
      "region": "shoulder_chest_and_torso",
      "finding": "The pass did not establish a scapular plane, pectoral mass, vertically oval ribcage, withers transition, loin, or convincing abdominal tuck."
    },
    {
      "rank": 3,
      "severity": "critical",
      "region": "pelvis_haunch_and_hind_chain",
      "finding": "The croup edits do not create gluteal, thigh, or hamstring masses, and the hip-to-hock chain remains mechanical."
    },
    {
      "rank": 4,
      "severity": "critical",
      "region": "head_and_neck",
      "finding": "Skull, muzzle, cheek, jaw, throat, stop, orbit, and ear roots remain unresolved, so Cockapoo likeness is not evaluable."
    },
    {
      "rank": 5,
      "severity": "severe",
      "region": "limbs_paws_and_surface_quality",
      "finding": "Rod-like limbs and tiny pad contacts remain, while one-sided manual pulls added dents and mirror error without anatomical gain."
    }
  ],
  "status_split": {
    "anatomy_g1": "REJECT",
    "likeness_g1b": "NOT_EVALUABLE",
    "production_topology": "BLOCKED",
    "rig": "BLOCKED",
    "groom": "BLOCKED",
    "animation": "BLOCKED",
    "final_render": "BLOCKED"
  },
  "next_bounded_strategy": [
    "Freeze v043 as rejected experiment evidence.",
    "Identify licensed anatomy-first canine bases and capture source and license receipts.",
    "Render every candidate nude in the same locked views before any morphing or groom work.",
    "Compare anatomy, joint chains, paws, topology, rig compatibility, editability, and license constraints.",
    "Treat user-supplied image-to-3D meshes only as silhouette or likeness evidence unless a separate topology review proves otherwise.",
    "Require explicit human approval before advancing a candidate past G1."
  ],
  "strongest_supportable_claim": "v043 proves a guarded visible manual-sculpt experiment and confirms that the current primitive-derived foundation should be abandoned. It does not establish acceptable canine anatomy or Cockapoo likeness.",
  "human_approval_required": true
}